2026-10-07 - Ad Hoc Budget Advisory Committee
Summary
Built from YouTube auto-generated captions; the agenda was not read and minutes are not yet posted. The captions begin partway through the meeting, after the executive presentations, and names and figures are as captioned and may be misspelled.
- Technology requests: A staff presenter walked through the IT list for the 2027 budget: server auditing and log collection, replacement of the on-premise data center systems and disaster recovery (end of life in 2027), a replacement access control server (in place since 2015) and access control and security cameras at three more fire stations, HR employee relations and recognition software, an AI program with governance and funding for AI-assisted meeting transcription, Starlink failover for police and fire sites, emergency blue light call boxes for recreation sites, and a distributed antenna system for the Bees Landing recreation center. See 2027 Technology Budget Requests.
- IT restructuring: The IT request includes three director-level positions (IT operations, chief information security officer, innovation), a senior GIS systems administrator and a business analyst. New positions total about $673,000, with about $630,000 in ongoing operating costs and about $220,000 one-time, for a total request of roughly $2.4 to $2.5 million.
- Greenway cameras: A councilmember asked whether cameras on utility poles along the West Ashley Greenway and bikeway were in the request. Staff said no: cameras in public parks are handled by the police department in its own budget, while IT covers city facilities. The councilmember said they would follow up with the police chief.
- Facilities, parks and urban forestry: The section requested about 24 new positions and five salary upgrades, ranked by priority, plus funding for contract maintenance, HVAC and mechanical work, building system and life-safety repairs (with the fire marshal), roofs and building envelopes, parking lot paving, vehicles and equipment, and priority tree removals. Specific items named include sand filters for the James Island recreation pool (the city will be down a pool for about two years), ball safety netting at Bay View, and artificial turf at Marion Square. See 2027 Facilities Parks and Urban Forestry Budget Requests.
- Context from staff: The section maintains about 120 parks, nearly 2,000 acres, and 211 buildings, and has delivered 165 projects worth about $1 billion in 12 years. The mayor supported growing the urban forestry crew, including for replanting after power line clearing. The neighborhood undergrounding coordinator position is proposed to be split with general fund support, since it is not a full-time job.
- Funding sources: Staff said parks costs are mostly operating funds, with hospitality and other tourism dollars typically used for tourist-facing spaces such as White Point Gardens and Marion Square. Unforeseen repairs, such as a sewer line at a nonprofit tenant's city-owned building, come from the maintenance budget or the deferred maintenance reserve.
- Outlook: The mayor said the city will likely not be able to accommodate everything requested. No votes were taken; the meeting adjourned. See also 2027 General Fund Budget Outlook.
Agenda
Agenda PDF posted; see Sources. Items not yet read.
Sources
- Agenda Center listing for this date: https://www.charleston-sc.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_10072026-11255
- Documents: Ad Hoc Budget Committee Agenda
- Agenda Center: https://www.charleston-sc.gov/AgendaCenter
- Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ax8F3IaFpBQ (City of Charleston YouTube channel)
Video
Transcript
*These are auto-generated captions; names and numbers may be misheard.
Transcript
00:00All right. Any other questions? I'm not
00:02seeing any.
00:06Um if there are no other questions on
00:09executive, we can move to some capital
00:12projects next.
00:13>> It's actually um it mayor.
00:15>> It all right.
00:19I think you're presenting on this.
00:24>> Yes, sir. Mr. Mayor, apologize. And I am
00:27not going to be nearly as uh I'm going
00:30to be pale in comparison to the last two
00:32presentations especially when it comes
00:34to the graphical representation for the
00:37budget proposal. I apologize. U
00:44>> let me do that here.
00:46>> Can you make that smaller? that this is
00:49a not exactly a uh graphically pleasing
00:54or appealing presentation. So,
00:57apologize. Let me zoom in here for you.
01:01Where am
01:04my presentation?
01:09Where is my zoom?
01:17me using the full extent of my bif
01:19focals on this.
01:20>> Yeah. No, I I apologize that is I was
01:23very illprepared. Here we go. Let's see
01:26sharing.
01:27>> I want to zoom in on this.
01:32>> Hi, I have some of the same thing. Would
01:34you like me to share? That way you don't
01:36have to worry about it.
01:38I can do uh if I'll do this real quick
01:41if let me know when when it becomes
01:43essentially uh viewable for the the
01:47details on the screen.
01:51All right, zoom in here.
01:59That better for presentate for
02:01visibility.
02:02>> Yep.
02:03>> All right. So, I'm just going to uh
02:06briefly there's quite a few uh new items
02:09that are on our uh request list, and
02:12I'll I'll go over uh each of them
02:14individually, but I'll I'll kind of uh
02:17go more in depth on the ones that are
02:19are of of higher priority or larger
02:22scale. Uh first is in including uh
02:25server auditing and log event collector.
02:27So this will allow us to gather more
02:30information for records retention both
02:32compliance requirements uh for CEIS as
02:36well as just overall cyber security uh
02:39improvements requasures
02:42who logs into systems computer systems
02:44and logs that information. Uh the next
02:47three actually are all a single project
02:52that are indivi three individual systems
02:54that make up the larger data center uh
02:57systems within our onremise data center.
02:59And these house all of our server
03:02systems. There's the data protection
03:04appliance server infrastructure and the
03:07data center storage. These are three
03:10components we have that are currently in
03:12our existing data center go end of life
03:13in 2027. So these systems are replacing
03:17those aging systems. Uh the disaster
03:20recovery actually is the fourth uh
03:23component of that overall uplift that
03:26needs to be uh replaced due to age. The
03:31next is the access control system. This
03:34system handles the access control for
03:37many of the city facilities. That's the
03:39badge access like city hall. the system
03:43that we currently have in place. This
03:44upgrades the server. That server has
03:47been in place since the implementation
03:49in the Gillyard back in 2015 and is end
03:53of life and needing to be replaced.
03:57The next line is actually tied to the
04:00fire budget, I it budget and is
04:03expanding the access control system to
04:05fire stations. This will add three
04:09threeuh fire stations to that list.
04:11implementing access control for those
04:14fire stations. We're phasing that
04:16project out over multiple years and just
04:19tackling a few stations at a time. So,
04:21this will address uh the installation at
04:23three fire stations in the upcoming
04:25year. Uh the next item, fire station
04:29security cameras, add security cameras
04:32to fire stations. again those the three
04:36uh fire stations that we'll be adding
04:39access control to. We also add security
04:42cameras on the exterior of the building.
04:45The fire department helps us uh identify
04:48those areas they most want to record
04:52primarily ingress egress of these
04:54stations so that uh to improve the
04:56security of those fire stations.
04:59The next two are for the HRE uh HR dep
05:05department employee relations
05:06development platform and recognition
05:09software. The the titles kind of explain
05:12exactly which each one of those systems
05:14do their uh HR's requested these to help
05:18track the employee relations and then
05:21recognition for their expansion of
05:25programs for employee retention uh and
05:27relations. Uh the next item is AI
05:32program. The city is looking at the IT
05:35department is looking at expanding and
05:37adopting a full-fledged AI program. This
05:41includes the uh deployment the
05:45development of governance for AI uh to
05:49employ with deploy AI for employees
05:53augmentation and improved enhanced
05:55productivity. But we want to lay the
05:58groundwork for ensuring that the AI
06:00usage is safe both for citizen and and
06:04employee data that we're protecting all
06:07of that information as we leverage these
06:09new AI systems. This also includes
06:13funding for use of uh contracting with
06:17vendors as we develop
06:20custom AI programs. One of the things
06:22we're looking to tackle this year with
06:24some funding is uh currently with the
06:28clerk of council's office leveraging AI
06:32tools to enhance the and improve the use
06:36of transcriptions for these meetings.
06:39Uh, and so really take the onus off of
06:43an employee having to sit down, listen
06:45to a meeting, and physically transcribe,
06:48type out exactly what's said, leveraging
06:50AI tools to automatically do that. that
06:53allows the employee to then verify that
06:55information, but should significantly
06:59uh shrink the time that it takes for
07:02these meetings to get transcribed,
07:03allowing them to do that much more
07:06quickly and then do uh freeing up time
07:08to do other things, expand and just make
07:10them more productive overall.
07:14the Starlink uh failover project. This
07:17is a project for to uh improve our
07:21resiliency and emergency management
07:23where we're looking at identifying
07:25police and fire locations where we
07:27really want to ensure communications in
07:30the event of a natural disaster.
07:32uh this this is leveraging the
07:34satellitebased Starlink uh
07:36communications so that if we have a
07:38large-scale natural disaster whether it
07:41be man-made or natural u to ensure
07:45communications and resiliency for
07:47communications at these locations. The
07:50emergency 911 phone blue light towers is
07:53a project to deploy uh which you
07:57probably familiar with. You've see them
07:59around college campuses. There's some on
08:01the the Ravenel Bridge, the those 911
08:04call boxes with the blue lights. We're
08:07looking at uh deploying several of these
08:09both at pools uh or any recreation
08:13sites. They're currently in design with
08:15some of the projects that are currently
08:17going into uh in development. John's
08:20Island as well as u on Playground Road,
08:24uh the WL Stevens Pool. Uh those are
08:26built into those projects. This project
08:29allows us to retrofit recreation sites
08:31and city facilities, city parks uh with
08:35these systems to uh improve uh safety
08:38and and allow for emergency
08:41communications u by citizens in these
08:44public spaces.
08:46The cellular dash system, this is
08:49specifically for the bees landing
08:51recreation center. This is an
08:52augmentation for the uh DA stands for
08:55distributed antenna system. uh for the
08:59cellular system when you go into that
09:01building the cellular reception in that
09:03area is very poor and then once you go
09:07into the building it's practically
09:09non-existent. This dash system uh puts
09:12an antenna on the roof distributes that
09:14within this uh facility so that when you
09:17go into the building you don't lose uh
09:19cell service.
09:22the IT department restructure. This
09:25project is actually uh calling for three
09:28positions. The restructuring of the
09:31department, what we're looking to do is
09:33as the IT department focuses on
09:37innovation, we want to expand the
09:39operation and the offerings of
09:41innovation with the city as well as
09:42improve the cyber security program uh
09:47that's handled by the IT department.
09:50This is calls for three positions. A
09:52director of IT operations, a chief
09:55information security officer as well as
09:57a director of innovation. These three uh
10:01positions would then be over those three
10:03divisions uh within the IT department
10:06allowing them to focus on the
10:07operations. The IT uh operate director
10:11of operations would focus on the
10:13day-to-day functions of the IT services.
10:16The director of innovation would work
10:18with GIS and our enterprise systems
10:20group to focus on the enterprise systems
10:24as well as exploring what new systems
10:27can be leveraged, how we can leverage it
10:30to improve the other departments to
10:33serve the other departments and their
10:34needs to serve the citizens. is looking
10:37at it uh amplifying as a force
10:40multiplier as a value ad for those
10:42departments leveraging new systems that
10:44would just make all the departments more
10:46efficient. That's something that uh the
10:49city really has an opportunity to
10:51improve in how we the IT department
10:54assist the other departments in
10:55facilitating their uh their core
10:59functions and the functions that they
11:01need to uh serve the citizens.
11:04The next is another position for a
11:07senior GIS systems uh administrator.
11:11This position is primarily focused will
11:14be focused on maintaining the physical
11:17GIS systems. Right now the GIS uh
11:20department Roberts uh is currently doing
11:23most of these functions that this this
11:26position is looking to cover. he he's
11:29having to be the administer day-to-day
11:32for a lot of these systems and this will
11:34allow him free up time for him to expand
11:37the systems uh and really focus more
11:40again on that innovation focused uh and
11:44data analytics positions that he already
11:47does right now but it will free him up
11:48to do a lot more of those functions. The
11:52business analyst uh is under the uh
11:55enterprise systems group uh that's also
11:59again focused on uh and then another
12:02innovation uh forward position
12:05leveraging
12:07how we currently utilize our enterprise
12:10systems. How can that be improved and
12:12optimized and get a lot more value out
12:15of those systems that we currently have?
12:20That uh that is it for
12:24the new projects. Just as this is a
12:27summary what we're looking at new
12:28position requests total approximately
12:30673,000.
12:33uh ongoing operational
12:35uh expenses is approximately 630,000
12:39with 220,000 as a one-time total budget
12:43request uh for the uh fiscal year uh 2.4
12:47million approximately 2.5 million
12:52and I know that was a lot of information
12:54all at once uh drinking from a fire
12:57hose. Are there any questions about any
12:59of those projects? Councilman Wearing,
13:01looks like you have a question.
13:03>> Yeah, [clears throat] I do. Not so much
13:04the project. We go back to the emergency
13:06911. I asked this when we had, you know,
13:10Chief Walker and his team uh present and
13:14I think some of this would have spilled
13:15over in your area. Uh
13:17>> yes, sir.
13:18>> Mr. Torres, uh we have these linear
13:20parks that we have enhanced and
13:22encouraging people to use the the West
13:25Ashley bikeway and the West Ashley
13:27Greenway that runs a good bit Actually,
13:31soon we'll have the u the bridge, the
13:33bike bridge over to Ashley. Um
13:37going back to Chief Mullen, uh there was
13:39some talk about putting u uh cameras on
13:44on high, so to speak, I guess, on maybe
13:46some of Dominion's uh power poles out
13:49there that would relay to camera at the
13:54police station so those bikeways and
13:56greenways could be monitored. Uh has is
14:00has is that incorporated in any of your
14:02um
14:04request?
14:04>> No, that no sir, that's not in included
14:07in any of these projects.
14:09Generally the the the police department,
14:11they they do currently have security
14:14cameras uh throughout the city and al in
14:16these projects and they handle that
14:18exclusively within their budget. They
14:21handle the the placement working with
14:23the contractors. So those types of
14:26security cameras uh are generally
14:28handled directly by the uh by the police
14:32department especially when they're in
14:33these public spaces in the parks.
14:35>> The cameras that the IT department
14:37generally uh handles are on city
14:41facilities. Uh we work with capital
14:44projects either when the the facility is
14:47being developed and built u or when
14:50there's a retrofit. And we work with the
14:53primarily with the fire department on
14:55their facilities, but those more
14:57public-f facing spaces, the police
14:59department handles generally directly.
15:02>> Well, in that case, mayor, I need to
15:04circle back with Chief Walker there
15:05because, you know, this again, we're
15:07doing things to enhance those spaces to
15:10to attract more people to use them. Uh,
15:13but you know, we need to have eyes on
15:15there. I mean some years ago uh people
15:18used um the greenway as access to break
15:22in the back of people's homes. Okay.
15:24>> So um
15:26>> um I mean we picked up security for a
15:30while over there but obviously
15:31technology can help with that a whole
15:33lot better. So um uh I was thinking it's
15:36crossed over into your area miss Mr.
15:38Torres but um
15:41>> no sir then there there is that gray
15:43area. Yeah, I do understand your answer.
15:46So maybe I need to go back and and
15:48circle back with Chief Walker because
15:50that's something that uh we've been
15:53talking about uh for a number of years,
15:55as I say, since Chief Mullen was here.
15:58So um uh and that's before we started
16:02repaving and resurfacing and putting in
16:05new pedestrian bridges and stuff for
16:07people to enjoy. um instead of waiting
16:12for something to happen, I think it's
16:13better to be proactive.
16:15So anyway, I'll circle back with with
16:18the chief on that.
16:20>> Good point. Yeah.
16:23>> Any other questions for it and I
16:31Okay, who we got next?
16:38By the way, Mr. stories. I think your
16:39graph I thought your graphics were
16:40terrific.
16:42>> Yeah, [laughter]
16:45>> I was very illprepared especially
16:47especially following the [laughter]
16:50>> um Mayor Parks says next.
16:53>> All right. Uh who's running on this one?
16:57We got
17:00Clark.
17:02>> Yes, sir. We got we've got Michael
17:04Kennedy, Clark, and myself. and I'll
17:06I'll quarterback us through the uh the
17:08PowerPoint.
17:10>> All right, sounds good. Edmond
17:13>> here.
17:14>> Floor is yours
17:16and screen is yours.
17:18>> Let me know when you all can see that.
17:26>> We got it.
17:29>> All right. Well, thank you everyone for
17:31allowing me this opportunity uh to to
17:34present these budget requests for 2027
17:36for facilities and capital project
17:38section. Um I fully realize that we have
17:43a lot of requests on the docket. Um and
17:46I'll just jump right in here and try to
17:48get through this as quickly as possible.
17:56Um is our mission statement right here.
17:59And as you're reading through that, I
18:00just want to add that um we're here to
18:02provide turn-key services to the city
18:05public city employees and the public. We
18:09design everything from small plantings
18:11in public spaces to new vertical
18:13infrastructure. Currently, our section
18:16maintains the majority of city's assets
18:17to provide infrastructure for city
18:19employees to conduct business and
18:20enhance public spaces to be enjoyed by
18:22the public. We're able to do this.
18:27We're able to do this.
18:30We are able to do this by the
18:32>> by the funding that that is available to
18:34us. We fully understand the challenges
18:37of carving out funding for services when
18:39there are so many needs throughout the
18:40city. And we understand that funding is
18:42limited.
18:44Uh just a quick overview on the
18:46presentation. It's really broken up
18:47between staffing requests and funding
18:49requests. Um and our structure here's a
18:53very short org chart here. Um we
18:57basically have three major divisions
18:59here. Capital projects, facilities, we
19:02also call them building ops and then
19:04parks ops. So really the vertical
19:07construction and then all the park
19:08spaces and horizontal green spaces and
19:11then capital projects. Um interestingly
19:14enough this time of year capital
19:16projects doesn't generally have a lot of
19:17requests for operational costs. It's all
19:20in their project budgets for the most
19:21part. This is primarily going to be
19:23building ops and and parks ops.
19:27Um, it's about 150 employees. It kind of
19:29varies a little bit dayto day. Um, and
19:33let me jump right in here. So, our
19:35staffing requests are big. I realize
19:37that we're making 30 requests here. You
19:39know, in looking at our our staff
19:42currently, we have a lot of employees
19:44that are starting to age out, especially
19:46more in facilities, a little bit more in
19:48grounds. Um, we're looking, we're
19:51constantly expanding our park spaces,
19:54our building infrastructure, and the
19:57only way that we can compensate with
19:58that is by adding staff. Capital
20:01Projects has been very good over the
20:02last um 12 years to to add a lot of
20:05infrastructure. So, that kind of breaks
20:07down to 24 new positions being
20:10requested, five salary upgrades to
20:12existing staff. Uh, and you can kind of
20:15see the mix and the breakdown right
20:16there. And again, it's going to be
20:18really heavy in facilities, parks, ops,
20:20and urban forestry.
20:25Um, on the lighter side of things, um,
20:28this is these are the smaller divisions
20:30in in parks. Basically, a couple of
20:33upgrades to some existing salaries. Um,
20:37you know, the employees are working
20:38hard. Uh, they're stepping up, taking on
20:41more responsibility, and we thought it'd
20:43be appropriate to compensate them for
20:44that. And then the last item there is
20:47the NSSF
20:49funds uh coordinator for parks. Um we've
20:53had this position for probably a little
20:55less than three years now. And this this
20:59employee is dedicated to working with
21:01neighborhoods and Dominion to help
21:03underground projects. And upon assessing
21:06that in the last three years, we've
21:08noticed that it's not a full-time job.
21:11And we would like to kind of split the
21:13funding for this position um from
21:16another funding source. I believe it
21:17would be general funds uh to help out
21:19with the workload here in capital
21:21projects. Um that individual is very
21:24excited to have that opportunity and
21:26fits right in our culture right here.
21:30Um jumping into facility management and
21:33services. I kind of broke this apart in
21:35management and services is kind of two
21:37different things. U facility management
21:39is really they're doing a lot of work
21:42orders. Uh and this is the the the
21:45breakdown of the request and everything
21:47that's indicated as a P over there is a
21:50priorities. So what I would encourage
21:52everyone to do when they're looking down
21:53and trying to sharpen the pencil and
21:55find funding is really look to those
21:58priority numbers. The higher the
21:59priority number is is the more urgent
22:02need that we have for that position. Um,
22:06this is the staff that performs most of
22:07the work orders and general maintenance
22:09in and on our buildings and foundation
22:11inventory. Over the last year, the
22:13senior staff have identified several
22:15positions severely needed to properly
22:17distribute the workload. Many of the
22:19existing staff are wearing multiple hats
22:21and as I said earlier, they're starting
22:23to age out, so we're constantly putting
22:25more responsibilities on the staff that
22:28is, you know, getting closer and closer
22:29to the end of their um career here at
22:31the city. So, we need to add more
22:33positions and kind of spread that out a
22:35little bit more. Um, the most urgent
22:38priorities here really I would identify
22:40as one, two, and eight.
22:46Jumping over to parks ops. Uh, this is
22:49the staff that touches all of our
22:50managed green spaces throughout the
22:52city. And I hope everyone has
22:53opportunities to go out into our park
22:55system because it is it's absolutely
22:57wonderful to experience that throughout
22:59the day and on the weekends. Over the
23:02last year, senior staff have identified
23:04several positions to really need to
23:06properly distribute workload. Many of
23:08the existing staff are taking on new
23:10parks and grounds to maintain and
23:11beautify. The most urgent ones here
23:14again are the top three that I'm listing
23:16here, two, six, and seven.
23:23urban forestry. So, this is an
23:25interesting group. It's a very tight
23:26group. Um, they have certainly a tall
23:29order with the tens of thousands of
23:31trees that the city has and we have a
23:33fairly small urban forestry group. Um,
23:36there's also the the initiative to
23:38relief the city and that's going to need
23:42some additional staff to support that
23:43effort. So, the most urgent needs on
23:46this one would be five and nine. uh this
23:49would really almost double the size of
23:52urban forestry for what they are right
23:53now.
23:55>> This is just if I may um something that
23:59I've been uh a strong advocate for uh if
24:02for no other reason. I mean, we
24:05mentioned the urban canopy. Um, but
24:08another effort that we all hear plenty
24:11about is
24:14um the trimming of trees around power
24:18lines. And this crew will help um you
24:23know in the bearing of power line
24:25efforts or initiative.
24:28Not that they would be doing the actual
24:29bearing, but just having the uh
24:33uh crews available to plant trees back
24:36when we do drop power lines. So, um it's
24:40a hell of a crew they have over there
24:42and I think it makes a lot of sense to
24:45uh expand it. So, I wanted to just throw
24:47that in there, that plug in there for
24:49you, Edmond. [snorts]
24:50>> Thank you, Mayor. This this is a very
24:52hardworking group, too.
24:55>> Agreed.
24:56>> Okay. This is the kind of the second
24:58half of it. Uh, a little bit more than
24:59halfway through this. So, now there's
25:01the funding requests. We have that
25:02staffing that we need to do be doing
25:04work orders on a constant basis. And
25:06then there's the funding requests, which
25:08are, you know, contract maintenance. The
25:10contract managers are hiring stuff out
25:12and they're managing that. It's
25:14equipment. It's a lot of other things
25:15that help support the staffing. So, it's
25:17kind of a two-pronged approach here. And
25:19again, I realize that that's a very
25:21large number there.
25:24Um, this is broken down a little
25:26differently now because we're getting
25:27into the depths of facilities. Here on
25:29the left hand side is HVAC mechanical
25:31and finishes. Um, and you can kind of
25:34see the spread of type of work here. Um,
25:37same thing, you know, it's it's like
25:38owning a home. Your HVAC needs to be
25:40replaced. We have dozens of facilities
25:43throughout the city that we're dealing
25:45with this on a constant basis here. So,
25:47we're trying to prioritize the the
25:49projects that need these things the
25:51most. In some cases, we have the ability
25:53to kind of stretch the service life of
25:55some of these things. And in some cases,
25:57we're getting closer and closer to the
25:58end of that service life, which is
26:00increasing that priority right there.
26:02Um, in this particular case here, we're
26:05looking at um
26:09really five and 11 are the two biggest
26:13ones. Um, and James Island wreck pool
26:17and sand filters. That's a little bit
26:19more critical just because we're down a
26:20pool in our inventory right now. We will
26:22be down for the next two years. So, it's
26:24absolutely critical that we fund that
26:26one to make sure that that pool is is
26:28operating as it needs to because
26:30there'll probably be a little bit more
26:31strain on it for the next two years
26:33before we build the two new facilities.
26:37Um on the right hand side there, this is
26:39building system repairs. So, this is
26:41more of kind of the the life safety
26:43realm here. Um, we've identified
26:46multiple projects that are very high on
26:48the priority list and working with the
26:50fire marshall on this. Um, and we're
26:52still kind of flushing some of this
26:54stuff out. It is it is feasible
26:56sometimes to move these back because the
26:58service life can be extended a little
27:01bit more with minor repairs and we're
27:03certainly digging deep into that to see
27:05if we can get a little bit more service
27:06life out of this equipment uh to help
27:09reduce that that budget request. But we
27:12would identify as three, four, six, and
27:15seven as the most needy on that list on
27:18the right hand side there.
27:24We always love to talk about roofs and
27:26building envelopes because that's what
27:27keeps the weather out, especially when
27:28we have a 4-in rainstorm like we did
27:30earlier in the week. Um, roofs and
27:33building envelope is absolutely
27:34critical. And if if you don't keep those
27:37service life up on those things with
27:39repairs and eventual replacement, you
27:42get water damage into a building and
27:44that starts to spend a lot of money with
27:46remediation, air monitoring and stuff
27:49like that. And we always like to
27:51identify the roof and building envelope
27:53replacements early on so we can get
27:55ahead of that. We have been doing a
27:57really good job over the last several
27:59years with that and I hope we can
28:00continue to do that. The most urgent
28:03items here would be 9,14 and 16.
28:12Um, this is kind of lower on the list
28:14here, but some of these items have been
28:16on our list for a number of years. I
28:18think you all have probably seen this
28:20previously when when Jason Kronberg has
28:22presented this items like the Bay View
28:25ball safety netting. We we've gotten a
28:27lot of uh constituents that have asked
28:29about that recently. um parking lot re
28:32rehabilitations. We have gravel lots in
28:34most cases where we have to constantly
28:36groom them. We try to pave them when we
28:38can. So, we've built a number of these
28:41in here and these are really kind of the
28:42highlights and and the highest ranked
28:44ones or park structures sites and
28:46equipment.
28:50Parks ops. So, another large group, the
28:55largest in in parks department,
28:57hardworking individuals, constantly
28:59going out there and doing everything
29:01that they can. They need some support
29:03too from time to time. Uh, and it's not
29:05always staff that they need. We
29:07identified a number of things that would
29:09kind of help their um their efficiency,
29:11help them store materials, um help with
29:14areas that are heavy wear and tear like
29:16the Maran Square Farmers Market,
29:18artificial turf. There's so much time
29:20and money that goes into keeping that
29:22area green for the public and it gets so
29:24much use. So, you know, converting that
29:26over to official turf, that would be a
29:29big win and would help on the general
29:31operating cost reductions of trying to
29:33keep that that lawn and green and and
29:35looking wonderful. Um, of course, we
29:37always need vehicles and equipment to
29:40support that staff. Those are a little
29:42bit more higher ranked because those
29:44individuals, they're in their vehicles
29:45and they're using it this equipment
29:47every single day.
29:52Um, I'm circling back to urban forestry
29:54and mayor, this kind of picks up a
29:56little bit of what you were were
29:57mentioning. We have a lot of priority
30:00one removals identified and and that
30:02really should be very high on the
30:04priority list. Those are trees that you
30:07know are getting probably end of the
30:09their lifespan or that they have uh some
30:12disease or rot in it and they're being
30:14identified uh per the tree survey as
30:17being removed earlier than later.
30:24And this would also be some of this
30:25would be uh contract labor. Maybe some
30:29can be done with in-house labor, but
30:30again we're overt taxing the existing
30:32staff that we have on. So this may be
30:34contracted labor out as well.
30:39So this is just kind of a summary page.
30:42I know they're big numbers. Just want to
30:44reiterate, you know, 120 parks in our
30:46system, almost 2,000 acres of of parks
30:50and open space.
30:52Several hundred buildings and building
30:54space that we're constantly in doing
30:56work orders every day to keep these
30:57businesses open. uh keep employees in
31:00there working and keep our green spaces
31:02green and enjoyable for the public.
31:07This next slide is really just kind of a
31:09breakdown of where that those funding
31:11requests are. There are a lot facilities
31:14management and facility services.
31:16Um parks and urban forestry and
31:19horiculture, they have a kind of a mix
31:21in there too. Um, but we are growing
31:23from a facility standpoint. And we're
31:25growing very quickly. And that kind of
31:28segus into this last slide of questions,
31:31but I wanted you to kind of focus in on
31:33that that little um additional text that
31:36I added in there. It's a really proud
31:39number to see that in 12 years,
31:42165 projects and a billion dollars worth
31:45of assets. And I personally take a lot
31:47of pride in that because I came to the
31:48city about 13 years ago and I've been
31:52involved with just about every one of
31:53those projects. Obviously, the team has
31:55done all this stuff, but it's it's
31:58really impressive what we've done here.
32:00And this is circling back on grounds and
32:03facilities. They need to maintain all
32:05this all these facilities and spaces
32:07that we've developed. And that's part of
32:09the reason why we have such a large
32:11budget request right now. Any
32:15questions?
32:16>> Something to be proud of, Edmond. I
32:17mean, know you and your team. I mean,
32:19that's uh that's impressive. Not to
32:22mention, I love the stats on the U
32:25120 parks. I didn't think I don't I
32:28didn't quite realize we almost have
32:302,000 acres and um 211 buildings. That's
32:36That's kind of mind-blowing. U
32:37Councilman Wearing, you have a question?
32:40>> Yeah. Yeah. Um listen uh excellently
32:44pres presented man I almost felt like I
32:46was it was almost professorial like a
32:49professor in class. So very well done.
32:52Um you're right 165 projects a billion
32:55dollars. That's some person. Um let me
32:59ask this is a question more of um um
33:02Miss Wharton. uh when we fund uh you
33:06know parks department does all of that
33:09come from a majority of it come from
33:11general funds or do we
33:14>> operationally
33:17>> council wearing probably mostly
33:19operationally yes for some of the
33:21facilities the repairs and uh deferred
33:24maintenance on the facilities we could
33:26use other funding sources depending on
33:28the facility type
33:29>> so we look at that to see what other
33:31funding sources we can use,
33:34>> right? One of the things I'm thinking
33:36about was uh do we ever think about for
33:39instance White Point Gardens or even
33:41Marian Square? Obviously tourist visit.
33:43>> Yeah, we we do we use hospitality
33:45typically for those or one of the other
33:47tourism dollars for any any upgrades
33:50that we do or maintenance on those areas
33:52or in those areas.
33:53>> All right. And when we have this back to
33:56Thank you, Miss W. Back to Mr. Deose.
33:59Um, we have a several situations I
34:03believe where with nonprofits who fill a
34:07huge void, um, we let them use a city
34:11building, I don't know, for a dollar a
34:13year or something like that, you know.
34:14Um um
34:17and I'm think there's a building next to
34:20Dart Hall Library that the city owns and
34:22we let
34:24it's kind of like darkness the light you
34:26know it's very tough situation where
34:28abused children you know and families
34:31get counsel uh they have a a sewage
34:35situation I don't know if it's ever come
34:37to your attention where they've had that
34:39line cleaned out a number of times I
34:41really believe it's a situation where
34:44sewer line coming into the building uh
34:46probably needs to be replaced. Should
34:49something like that pop up,
34:53is there a carveout in a budget request
34:55that you have for example in front of us
34:57or we have to scramble in a different
34:59direction?
35:01>> Unforeseen costs like that, if that
35:03became like an emergency repair, we
35:05would go into um really just the
35:08maintenance budget to pay for that if it
35:10if it's something that that budget can
35:12absorb. We always know there's going to
35:14be unforeseen in all of our projects and
35:17all of our facilities. So, we try to
35:19account for that. Um, if we know it's
35:22coming, we want to identify it as a new
35:25program and have a cost and try to limp
35:27along until, you know, we can get
35:28approval on that. So, it really kind of
35:31just depends on the situation.
35:33>> Um, Council Wearing, if I could add to
35:35that, we also have deferred maintenance
35:38that we reserve every year for those
35:40types of things as well. So,
35:42>> Okay. Good. Thanks a lot. Thanks again,
35:44Mr. Mos, for your presentation. Well
35:46done.
35:47>> Welcome.
35:49>> Questions.
35:52>> Any I agree.
35:55I'm You know, Councilman Wearing, you
35:57didn't really give those same accolades
36:00on the presentation I gave, but
36:02[laughter] it's okay.
36:05>> Well, you know, I I had my sunglasses on
36:07with all those graphics you had up
36:09there.
36:09>> Yeah. [laughter]
36:12Thank you. I agree. That was very well
36:14done and um very thoughtful and um
36:18appreciate the time and effort that you
36:20and your team put into putting that
36:22together. And it is a big number. Uh we
36:25we um in all likelihood will not be able
36:28to uh accommodate everything, but uh I
36:31think it was very thorough and and
36:34um like I say, well thought out. So
36:36appreciate the effort there. any any
36:38other questions from any of the other um
36:41ad hoc committee members on uh this
36:45presentation.
36:50Okay, let's do we have another one?
36:53>> Nope, that was it, mayor.
36:56>> All right. Well, um
36:59uh if there's nothing else for the good
37:01of the cause, then uh this meeting I
37:04will call adjourned and appreciate
37:07everybody's Simon.
```*
