2026-09-29 - Joint Maintenance & Development-Finance
Summary
Based on auto-generated captions; names and figures may be misheard.
- Vehicle replacement plan: The joint committee, chaired by Lavar Click-Bruce, met from about 4:19 to 4:39 PM with Maria Perez and Victor G. Davila to review the city's first comprehensive vehicle replacement plan. The chair said police, fire and public works used to come separately for vehicles, and the council asked for one plan. Chris Cignoli built it with the police and fire departments in June 2026.
- The numbers: The city has about 883 vehicles and pieces of equipment, with a fleet value of more than $100 million. A rule of thumb of replacing vehicles about every 10 years suggested roughly $10 million a year; the first draft came to about $11 million before being cut to $6 million. The first-year purchase is 73 vehicles: 36 police, 7 fire, 24 general fund and 6 enterprise fund (trash). That is about $2.2 million for police, $510,000 for fire, $1.3 million for the general fund and $1.8 million for the enterprise fund. Later years run about 100 pieces of equipment, with 123 planned next year after some purchases were pushed back.
- How it works: The $6 million would be raised by a bond authorization, to go before the full council the following Monday. Police and fire will buy their own vehicles from separate accounts; the city buys through state contracts, trades in old vehicles, and uses some state road money (Chapter 90) for two street sweepers. Cignoli said lead times are 8 to 12 months for trash trucks and about 6 months for passenger vehicles, and an ordered fire truck is more than a year out. The plan is to be updated about every two years.
- Questions: Members asked how needs were set (fire dropped a truck because it had one on order and bought two used; police gave a minimum need), about police reserve vehicles, and about snow plows. Cignoli said the plow fleet is in good shape, with 22 large trucks and about 15 pickups and 3 small dump trucks with plows, and that a contractor bid for winter plowing went out about three weeks earlier. Some new trash trucks are included.
- Outcome: No recommendation was voted. The chair said the item still has to go to a Finance subcommittee and that, speaking for himself, it is a need for the city; the plan was to be circulated to all councilors. See $6M citywide vehicles bond authorization.
Sources
Video
Transcript
These are auto-generated captions; names and numbers may be misheard.
Transcript
00:00All
00:05>> [music]
00:13>> right, we're going to go ahead and get
00:14started. It is um Tuesday, September
00:1829th, approximately 4:19, and we're
00:22looking to start our joint maintenance
00:23and development and finance committee
00:25meeting. Um on the agenda is discussion
00:29and review of the vehicle,
00:31excuse me, vehicle replacement plan. And
00:34here we have with us councelor
00:36um Perez and we have our city team
00:40leaders here. Uh we also have councelor
00:44Victor Davila just joined us. Um,
00:48>> so I don't know want to start Lindsay or
00:50>> I guess I'll just start by saying I
00:52don't know if the council remembers a
00:54couple years ago I said that because the
00:56police would come for vehicles, fire
00:58would come, DPW would come and it made
01:00more sense for us to have one
01:01comprehensive plan so the council could
01:04have an understanding of what we need
01:05currently, what we need going forward.
01:08So um
01:11Chris Signoli was um gracious enough to
01:14offer to lead this.
01:16>> Yeah. and put together a plan. He met
01:18with fire, he met with police. He is now
01:20making the decisions. He's make they
01:22made them together deciding what. Um so
01:25we will be coming in front of you on
01:27Monday for $6 million bond for vehicles
01:30for all the departments. Um so I will
01:33turn it over to Chris while he uh goes
01:37through the plan with you and I want to
01:39show it to the subcommittees before we
01:40went in front of council Monday night.
01:42>> Thank you.
01:42>> Sure. And I'll I'll give you a copy.
01:48Some of these are single-sided,
01:50double-sided. I don't want need you or
01:52you know, you don't have to read it. I
01:54just want you to have a copy and we'll
01:55get one to everybody else on the
01:58council. Thank you.
01:59>> Um uh the front part of it is just a
02:01narrative going over all the numbers. We
02:04completed this back in June and actually
02:06when we completed it uh and what what's
02:10in there the total number of vehicles
02:12vehicles in every department the age the
02:13mileage uh all their use and everything
02:16and and it's split up uh by police
02:19department fire department
02:22uh by department within the city on the
02:25general fund and then the enterprise
02:26fund which is our stuff uh as well. So,
02:29we kind of split it up into th those
02:30four police places. When we did the plan
02:34initially back in June, um, one of the
02:38things we came up with is that we have a
02:39value of our fleet of over hund00
02:42million between everything. And, you
02:46know, just rule of thumb, vehicles last
02:4810 years or so. So, she kicks me every
02:52time I say this number. Roughly, you
02:53should be spending like $10 million a
02:55year. Just ballpark.
02:57>> Um,
02:57>> I do. Yeah, n she said no. Well, we came
03:00out with about $11 million for this
03:02year. We went back and reviewed
03:04everything and came back down to the six
03:05million. And just from a highlight of
03:12just want to make sure I'm looking at
03:13the
03:17and in there too, it talks about the
03:19past uh money that we've spent, whether
03:22it's been uh budget money, whether it's
03:25been uh bonding, or whether it's been
03:27free cash. So that's all listed in
03:29there. But basically what we are looking
03:31at is the city overhaul has about 883
03:35vehicles pieces of equipment. Uh we are
03:38looking to do a purchase right now of
03:42um 73 vehicles, 36 of them police
03:45department, seven in the fire
03:46department, 24 general fund, six in the
03:49enterprise fund, and that totals up to
03:51the $6 million. Um, and just by
03:55splitting that up,
03:58uh, up.
04:00Um,
04:04is
04:07Oh, I changed it around. Okay. No, I
04:09just wanted to I just wanted to double
04:11check on that. Um, about 2 mill 2.2
04:15million is police department, 510,000 is
04:17fire department, 1.3 is general fund,
04:20and 1.8 Eight is enterprise fund. Um
04:24we're coming in front of the council
04:26Monday, next month. Next Monday. Uh for
04:29the $6 million. Um police and fire are
04:33going to be buying their own stuff. All
04:35I'm going to be doing on their side is
04:37just following their money. Um we will
04:40then start our purchases.
04:42Attached to this. The stuff you see on
04:44the big 11 by17 is just very detailed
04:46data of all the different departments,
04:49how much vehicles would cost, and it's
04:51laid out over a five-year plan um of
04:54what we wanted to of what we wanted to
04:57purchase. And the idea was is that we
05:00kind of wanted to get to an average
05:01number every year of what we're going to
05:02do. And I'm sure this time next year um
05:06not you but we'll be back talking about
05:09different things uh for the next year
05:12going on. But really what we've done is
05:14we've gone through every piece of
05:16equipment and put it into the plan. It's
05:18either being done in the next 5 years or
05:20it's post five years and the cost
05:23associated with it. Um so that if we
05:27need to purchase basically anything we
05:28have the costs for those. Uh, and as I
05:32said, we're doing 73 vehicles this year.
05:35Next year, because we bump some back be
05:37123. And every year it's about 100 um
05:40100 pieces of equipment. And when you
05:43average everything out, every vehicle is
05:45about average $100,000. Trash trucks are
05:47400.
05:49Uh, fire department vehicles are
05:51anywhere between 1 and 2 million.
05:53Passenger vehicles about 30 30,000 or
05:56so. And we have a bunch of uh a real big
05:59mix of everything that's going in there
06:01uh this year.
06:04Uh and that's kind of it. We have it
06:06split up in there of the number of
06:09vehicles uh per department
06:12um and what they're what they're going
06:14to get every year or what they're
06:16proposed to get every year and the cost
06:18associated with that. Um, in the past,
06:22and I don't think we've done it for at
06:23least 5 years, we used to have it in the
06:26budget. We would get we would buy say $6
06:28million worth of vehicles. Um, we would
06:31do it over five years. So, I would have
06:33a line item in my budget. Uh, right now
06:37we're done. I think everything is done.
06:39There is no vehicle payments in the
06:41budget anymore. Um, in the past we did
06:45some, but I think we made our last
06:47payment this year on some trash trucks
06:49that we bought in the past. So, um,
06:51that's really where we are with this.
06:53Um, and it's a comprehensive plan.
06:56Again, it includes everything police and
06:58fire. They were heavily involved. So,
07:01um, I can't thank Juan enough from the
07:03police department with all their
07:04vehicles. So, um, when we had to cut
07:07down, met with them, uh, talked with the
07:10fire department. Uh, fire department has
07:12a has one one truck on order and they
07:17just bought two. They bought they bought
07:19two used vehicles. So, um, right now
07:22they're kind of in okay shape. Um, but
07:24the one they ordered is over a year. I
07:27know it's been over a year.
07:28>> Still like a backlog with those fire
07:30trucks.
07:30>> Yeah, those fire trucks. Right now, our
07:32trash trucks are anywhere between 8 to
07:3412 months.
07:35uh passenger vehicles now about 6
07:36months. Nobody's keeping any inventory.
07:38So everything that we order uh is
07:41getting ordered, but what we we're
07:43finding out is that a lot of entities
07:45are putting orders in and then having
07:47the funding taken. So we've been like uh
07:50a couple sweepers. We're going to be
07:51putting an order in for them. Um
07:54they have them on the lot, so we may get
07:56them in, you know, a couple weeks. So
07:58but everything's taken a long time to
08:00get.
08:00>> So Chris, thank you for that. No
08:02problem. Lindsay, uh, where's the 6
08:04million coming from? Is it free cash?
08:06You looking?
08:07>> No, we're looking to bond. We're going
08:08to ask you for a bond authorization.
08:10Yes.
08:11>> So, what happened with the um uh the
08:14cars that we place? What happens with
08:16those?
08:16>> They all get traded in. Um, virtually
08:19every vehicle that we're doing, we trade
08:21in. Um, and the the cost that we have in
08:25here, uh, is a purchase cost. So, when
08:28we trade in a trash truck or we trade in
08:30whatever, we end up getting money back,
08:32you know, handful of uh mostly with
08:35equipment, we get pretty good money. The
08:37vehicles, we don't get really good, but
08:38you get, you know, two, three, $4,000,
08:41you know, um on some of the vehicles.
08:43So, what we end up doing in the end is
08:45we I track it and if we end up with
08:47enough money, we get to purchase one
08:49more vehicle or something like that. So,
08:52um and the prices, we buy everything off
08:54a state contract. So, uh, we don't go
08:57out to bid, but we go out to kind of bid
08:59through state contracts. So, we go out
09:01to vendors that, um, can, you know, we
09:04agree with them today, they can order it
09:06tomorrow. So, um, we get a couple
09:08different prices and these are all
09:10people that, you know, they do this for
09:11a living. So, um, they have state
09:13contract numbers and we work everything
09:15right through procurement law department
09:17with contracts.
09:20Um, and this me just asking I'm pretty
09:22sure you guys are definitely a
09:24comprehensive plan. Uh, do we go on
09:27based off of needs um each department
09:32kind of we price it out or determine uh
09:35say for instance like fire needed 20. We
09:38said all right we can give you seven
09:40this time around. How do we determine
09:42like what what vehicles were for each
09:44department? Fire was actually easy
09:46because they had an engine. Yeah.
09:48>> And then they had
09:50uh a bunch of small support vehicles,
09:52SUV style vehicles. So on fire with them
09:55having the one on order and purchasing
09:57two, we just eliminated one truck. with
10:00police. I sat down with them and said,
10:03you know, they're dealing with all the
10:05passenger vehicles and there's some
10:06motorcycles and a couple other things in
10:08there, but uh basically it was like,
10:10hey, um you know, they said to us, what
10:13we want is this. What we really, really,
10:15really, really need is this number. And
10:17we did the same thing on our side. Uh
10:20one of the things that we are doing is
10:21we actually are using some of our
10:23chapter 90 money.
10:24>> Yeah.
10:24>> To buy some of the vehicles for the DPW
10:26sweepers and some other equipment. So,
10:29um, yeah, nobody's happy, but you know,
10:32we're never happy.
10:34>> It's more of a team approach now, saying
10:36that we,
10:37>> you know, we all know we can't spend 10
10:3910 million a year on vehicles. So, it's
10:41what do you need? What has to be
10:42replaced? They looked at the inventory,
10:44the mileage on the car, etc., the
10:46condition,
10:47>> every
10:48>> I'm sorry. Every vehicle except for
10:50police and fire, we take care of.
10:52>> Yeah. So, inside of our Cardigrat
10:53system, we know, you know, and our guys
10:56know that, hey, the car Lavar drives is
10:58piece of crap. We need to fix it. You
11:00know, it's in here every two weeks for
11:02this, this, this, this, and this. And we
11:04also go through a lot of things with the
11:06um passenger vehicles. A number of years
11:08ago, we bought
11:10>> Ford Focuses.
11:11>> Yeah.
11:11>> And Ford Focus is now all the
11:13transmissions are failing at 85 90,000
11:16miles.
11:17>> So, all those are going away. the the
11:20newer vehicles that we're buying, the
11:22Equinoxes uh and the SUV styles are
11:25actually turning out to be nice cars and
11:28those things should be around for a
11:29while. Like you should be able to get
11:31150,000 miles out of those vehicles, no
11:34problem.
11:35>> Um but a lot of, you know, we have a lot
11:37of pickups um and specialized equipment,
11:41especially when you get in, you know,
11:42some of the DPW and some of the park
11:44stuff with log trucks and things like
11:46that. you know, we have a traffic truck
11:47in here that has um you know, a lift on
11:50the back of it. So, you get into real
11:52specific ones like that.
11:54>> So, I want to commend you all for
11:55working and hearing the council because
11:57you don't hear that a lot for uh hearing
12:00us and uh taking our suggestion and uh
12:02doing this. So, Chris, thank you for
12:04taking this on from us here.
12:06>> You're welcome. And we will probably do
12:08this every two years because stuff just
12:10changes so radically. Uh prices are
12:13starting to come down a little bit. So
12:14my hope is that we can get some pretty
12:16good prices, but um we will be updating
12:18this every so often uh to make sure we
12:21have good numbers.
12:22>> Okay.
12:23>> Uh councilors, you have anything else?
12:25Councelor Davala, councelor Perez,
12:28>> I think it's more this year, you know,
12:32because in the past we were having
12:33questions about it and looking at the
12:35report is very selfexplanatory
12:38and the need of purchasing this car
12:41because I think that was one of the
12:42issues why we purchased a car that we
12:45didn't have the education or
12:46understanding why. And this bring us to
12:49the why. Uh, one of the things that I
12:51was going to ask is, um, and it's in the
12:54police department. Um, do you have like
12:56a reserve? You know, the police always
12:58doing chasing and all that and car gets
13:01destroyed and we're not able to, you
13:04know what I'm saying? What happens? And
13:06if that is in the market as well, you
13:08know.
13:09>> Yeah. They have they have some reserve
13:11vehicles and what they end up doing is
13:15what, you know, they do end up with
13:16total vehicles throughout the year.
13:18That's for sure.
13:19uh their vehicles do run 24/7, they do
13:22have extra ones and uh what ends up
13:25happening is vehicles that are used say
13:28by a captain or something that's just
13:30used sometimes during the day all of a
13:31sudden he has to give that up now it
13:33becomes a 247 vehicle. So, uh that's why
13:36on their list they had I don't know I
13:38can't remember the number again. We had
13:40uh
13:4736 36 vehicles for the police
13:49department. So, um you know, and if
13:53they're all
13:55um trying to remember what what kind
13:58they are now. I can't remember what but
13:59they're all the same kind now. They're
14:01not buying they had uh three or four
14:04different styles. They're all buying the
14:05same things now. Uh they're SUV styles.
14:09Yeah, I can't remember the name. I can't
14:12[clears throat]
14:14go
14:16because the price of everything now.
14:17They had Crown Vicks which aren't being
14:18made anymore cars. But so yeah,
14:21everything with them is and they with
14:24theirs they auction their stuff. All
14:27their dead stuff they end up auctioning
14:28it because they also auction off uh uh
14:31cars that they seize.
14:33>> Mhm. And a lot of company like people
14:35will come in and buy 50 of these things
14:37for 10 grand. But yeah,
14:43>> council good.
14:47>> Thank you. Uh Mr. Chair, good afternoon
14:49to all and Chris and um
14:54Kathy, thank you for the presentation.
14:55Uh Chris, quick question. I believe you
14:57say that police is going to be buying
14:59going to be buying their own but they're
15:01going to be buying that with a bond of
15:03$6 million right what the portion is
15:06>> correct
15:08>> okay so we give the money they do their
15:10own purchasing
15:11>> yes what we'll do is we will the
15:14accounts uh will be set up uh probably
15:18three different accounts uh wills have
15:20an account uh police will have one fire
15:22will have one and they'll begin
15:24purchasing their vehicles off of it. Uh
15:27they give me all the information and I
15:29just follow it.
15:30>> Right. Now, I saw Chris on your side of
15:32the world. I think you mentioned that
15:33you're going to be using some chapter 90
15:35money to buy some vehicles for you. Does
15:37that include snow plowers? Uh
15:39>> no. We uh right now for for snow plows,
15:43we are in very good shape. Over the last
15:45four or five years, we've purchased uh
15:47new new uh dump trucks plows. So, we're
15:50in good shape for that. The two vehicles
15:52that we're purchasing are going to be
15:53street sweepers.
15:55How many How many small plowers do we
15:57have, by the way?
15:58>> Uh large size, we have 22.
16:01>> Those are the big trucks.
16:02>> Yeah, big trucks. And we have uh 15 or
16:06so pickup trucks that have uh plows on
16:09them. We have three small dump trucks
16:12that have plows on them. So from a
16:14plowing standpoint, you know, we put out
16:16about uh 40 of our own trucks, but of
16:19those 15 of those are inspectors who are
16:21plowing at the same time uh from an
16:24inspection standpoint. But yeah, the big
16:26dump dump trucks are fine. Uh we do need
16:29two sweepers and uh a bunch of other
16:33miscellaneous equipment. And I I got
16:36here it's split up by all the
16:37departments in uh
16:39>> in inside of uh the general fund. Now
16:42Chris, um when you said staying on the
16:45snow plow situation because you know
16:47winter is coming that we're going to
16:49augment that with the contractors.
16:50Correct.
16:51>> Correct. Our bid went out uh three weeks
16:55ago uh was published and we are in
16:59contact with all of our entities. We've
17:01already had uh some of our standard
17:04contractors already filling out
17:05paperwork for us.
17:07>> Okay. No. I'm sorry. And did you see
17:09you're going to get any trash trash
17:11trucks or No.
17:12>> Uh yeah, we have I believe two
17:18I believe it's two fully automated and
17:21one rear loader
17:24uh that we're getting on this either two
17:26or three. Uh I can't remember now.
17:31>> But yeah, we are getting uh some new
17:34trash trucks.
17:35>> Okay. Now, the plan, I believe, says
17:36we're going to be doing this every two
17:38years to keep up with attrition.
17:39Correct.
17:40>> Correct.
17:41>> Okay. All right. Uh, thank you, Chris.
17:43Thank you, Kathy. Um, thank you, Mr.
17:45Chair.
17:46>> Thank you, Councelor Davo. Three three
17:48semi-automated trucks.
17:50>> All right. Thanks, Chris.
17:51>> Yeah.
17:54>> Else, councelor.
17:57>> All right. Uh, will this be going to
17:58finance on Monday? it. We will have a
18:01finance committee in this and they will
18:02and and we'll send around these for all
18:04counselors to have before that meeting
18:06but she we are going to have a finance
18:08subcommittee meeting.
18:09>> Okay.
18:10>> So I guess we'll
18:13go for
18:14>> is this isn't included in the packet
18:17correct in the agenda packet?
18:19>> I don't think it is.
18:21>> No.
18:22>> So if you have it we can send it to
18:24Daisy.
18:25>> Yeah. Give it to Daisy and have her send
18:26it out because she knows everybody's the
18:28million emails.
18:29Oh,
18:30>> so she'll get it all to
18:31>> Yeah, she can get it all to them.
18:33>> Okay. So, just for the record, we won't
18:34make a recommendation today, but as far
18:37as myself, council can't speak for a
18:39doubt. I think we're good on our end,
18:41but we want to make sure it goes before
18:43our finance before we make a
18:44recommendation to go as we bring to the
18:46floor on Monday night, but uh I would
18:49dive into this more deeply over the
18:51weekend and stuff, but
18:53>> it's a need. It's a it's a need for our
18:55city. And again, I thank I thank you all
18:57for doing this uh for us and uh making
19:00sure that our our uh vehicle stocks are
19:02in in place for for our residents and
19:05our employees that need them. So,
19:07>> and anybody who's got questions, just
19:09give me a yell.
19:10>> Yep. So,
19:14>> recommend C2.
19:21>> Yep. So,
19:23>> I'll get I'll get this to I'll get the
19:25file to Daisy.
19:26>> Y she can get it.
19:27>> Yeah. All right. Thank you so much. I'm
19:30close with this meeting and got 439 on
19:32Tuesday, September 29th.