What: Certificate of Appropriateness COA2026-062 for Caroline Edwards, 523 Summit Street (Pepper-McClung House, contributing, West End Historic Overlay District 109): a new porch staircase.
Where it stands: denied August 5, 2026, 8-1.
Next: nothing further recorded.
The proposal
A painted wood staircase on the north side leading from the front porch to the side yard.
Requires removal of about 3 feet 8 inches of porch railing.
No one spoke for or against.
Staff position
Staff found it incongruous because the stairs are in a highly visible part of the property and the railing is a character-defining feature.
Decision
Denied on August 5, 2026, 8-1 (C.J. Idol moved, Marilyn Little seconded; Jason Thiel opposed).